IMMIGRATION DETENTION IN THE MEDIA
President Trump’s issuance of executive orders calling for an expansion of immigration enforcement and banning travel from 7 countries allegedly affiliated with terrorism caused a public and media uproar. It also threw a spotlight on the vast yet shadowy U.S. immigration detention system.
In February 2017, we released a 77-page report on how immigration detention has been portrayed in the media since 2009.
The report, Immigration Detention the Media: Missing Migrant Voices and the Need for Humanistic Storytelling, assesses media coverage of immigration detention over the past 8 years and surveys prominent immigration journalists to reveal that migrant voices and experiences have been systematically silenced in the mainstream media.
Findings
Of the top 8 newspapers in the United States, there were only 845 articles that focused primarily on immigration detention between 2009 and 2016.
However, immigration detention is three times more visible now than in 2009. Coverage is largely critical, highlighting flaws and abuses within the system.
The quality of coverage is still lacking. The complex realities of the detention system remain hidden from public view and there remains a dearth of first-hand migrant accounts. The main reason behind this is that the U.S. government makes it difficult for reporters to access people in detention.
Recommendations
• Media outlets should focus on solutions-based coverage.
• Media-makers should increase their efforts to include first-hand migrant accounts in their reporting, and collaborate with organizations like CIVIC that serve migrants in detention and affected communities.
• The U.S. government should ease restrictions on reporters when visiting immigration detention facilities.
• Non-profit organizations serving immigrants should embrace storytelling as a means for social change.
Read the full report:
Immigration Detention the Media: Missing Migrant Voices and the Need for Humanistic Storytelling